Each Instance Carrie Underwood’s Songs Were Sung on ‘American Idol’ Season 23

Carrie Underwood: A Journey Back Home

Some mornings start off like any other, and then there’s news that makes you stop. For fans of Carrie Underwood, the announcement of her returning to the show that started it all was a big moment. She first stepped into the spotlight during season 4 of a certain singing competition, and it’s safe to say she never really left our hearts. In 2024, she came back in a new role – taking over for Katy Perry as a judge alongside Luke Bryan and Lionel Richie for the show’s 23rd season.

Underwood reflected on her journey in an announcement video, saying, “I went from nobody knowing my name to tens of millions of people watching the show.” I guess it’s one of those full-circle moments we all imagine but rarely see. Her impact on aspiring artists is palpable, as she shared in a radio interview her approach to judging: “Be honest but still kind.” It’s kind of like how you’d wish someone would critique your singing if you dared to perform at karaoke night.

As season 23 rolled out, Underwood expressed how much her initial experience on the show had shaped her life. Now, she has the opportunity to shape others’ lives – it seems a fair trade. Contestants openly showed their love for Underwood by performing her songs during auditions. I heard Champlin’s audition involved a heartfelt rendition of “Good Girl,” recalling her early days singing at the Grapevine Opry in Texas.

Then there was JMarie from New York, who gave “Before He Cheats” a fresh twist in March 2025. She humorously called it a “hood anthem,” acknowledging its universal appeal. And that extra lyric she added – “Maybe next time he’ll think before he cheats / ‘Cause he ain’t that dumb” – was something even Underwood appreciated, saying it made her forget she ever sang it herself.

Yani’s song choice was also something to note. Before surprising everyone with “Waiting All Day for Sunday Night,” he hinted at its deep roots. Underwood found it “clever,” giving him the golden ticket to Hollywood.

One can’t overlook Roberts’ soulful take on “Undo It” in May 2025, complete with a cowboy hat flair. Underwood couldn’t hide her excitement: “That was so much fun!”

Underwood’s return has undeniably left an imprint on this new batch of artists – perhaps more than we realize now. For those interested in more about Carrie’s journey or similar stories in the music world, you might want to check out BBC Entertainment & Arts.

I guess these moments remind us why we tune in – not just for nostalgia but for hope and inspiration too. And maybe, just maybe, to see ourselves up there one day.