California Mother Abducted and Coerced into Bank Heist Wrongly Portrayed as a Criminal in Court
Surviving Trauma: A Story of Resilience and Redemption
On November 20, 2000, Michelle Renee and her 7-year-old daughter Breea experienced a horror that forever altered their lives. The only fears Breea had known were those conjured by her imagination, but this night was different. Three masked men invaded their home, shattering their sense of safety.
Michelle recalled her daughter’s earlier warning: “Mom, there’s somebody outside the window.” Initially dismissing it as child’s play, Michelle soon realized the terrifying truth. The men had been watching them, waiting for the perfect moment to strike. That night, they held Michelle and Breea at gunpoint in their living room.
The intruders revealed they had been stalking the 35-year-old bank manager for months. Using manipulation tactics, they coerced Michelle into robbing her own bank. As she sat bound with duct tape alongside her daughter, Michelle heard the ringleader communicating with a woman on a two-way radio-an unsettling detail that would later prove crucial.
Before dawn, Michelle, her roommate Kimbra, and Breea were strapped with fake dynamite by these men who called themselves “Money One” and “Money Two.” The ringleader handed Michelle what appeared to be a detonation device, threatening her daughter’s life if she failed to comply.
With dynamite on her back and a gun aimed at her side, Michelle drove to the bank under duress. She managed to alert her colleagues of the situation, whispering about the explosives strapped to her body as she cleared out the vault. Despite her terror, Michelle walked out with $360,000-money she never wanted.
After dropping off the cash as instructed, she raced home in fear for Breea’s life. Finding the house eerily silent upon return, she was met with relief when Breea’s voice called out from the closet where she’d been left.
Authorities quickly got involved. The FBI and San Diego Sheriff’s Department descended upon the scene, uncovering that the dynamite was fake-a mere illusion crafted from painted dowels. Thanks to Michelle’s attention to detail and memory for faces, investigators zeroed in on a suspect: Christopher Butler.
Butler was a familiar face; he’d posed as a potential client at Michelle’s bank days before the crime. His accomplices included his fiancée Lisa Ramirez and two men with gang ties-Christopher Huggins and Robert Ortiz. Within days of their identification, law enforcement apprehended Butler and Ramirez during a traffic stop.
The investigation unraveled quickly with evidence piling up: a black bag filled with gloves and masks, along with traces of stolen money found in Butler’s car trunk. Yet when the trial began in June 2002, both Butler and Ramirez denied involvement, attempting instead to implicate Michelle.
Despite an arduous courtroom battle where defense attorneys attacked Michelle’s credibility by dredging up personal history and financial struggles-falsified resumes and past bankruptcy-the jury eventually saw through these diversions. Butler was convicted of robbery and kidnapping charges while Ramirez walked free due to lack of admissible evidence against her.
This ordeal left lasting scars on Michelle and Breea’s lives. For years they battled post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD), but emerged stronger for it. They turned their experience into advocacy by writing books like “Held Hostage” which became a TV movie adaptation. Together they spoke publicly about surviving trauma.
Breea found new challenges beyond overcoming PTSD when diagnosed with multiple sclerosis (MS) at age 18-a fight that tested her resilience once more. But just as before when faced with adversity during captivity years prior-Breea persevered through rehabilitation processes over many months regaining abilities once thought lost forever due to
For more details, see this background on crime trends.
